Preview image for The Birchbright Restitution

The Birchbright Restitution

Clarissa Cottonmoon was looking at the clock. As the director of the Birchbright Theater, she was used to things running on time. But it was 9:37 am, on a wet Tuesday in March, and neither of her assistants were here. The theater was doing Anything Goes in May; rehearsals kicked off next week. The time between now and then had been thoroughly audited by Clarissa, each moment itemized and assigned, each task chained to the others. This information lived both on the director’s laptop and in her head. The clock in question was an old grandfather donated for a show years ago; it had migrated, eventually, into her dusty office. It, not her, she thought sometimes, was the true theater director. There was so much to do, and her only currency for doing it was scant, unmerciful time. But now 37 minutes were gone, times two. She was about to call one of them when she heard a door open in the lobby. When she went out, her assistants were there: Corey and Chelsea. They were shaking off the rain. Corey smiled as Clarissa came out of her office, but Chelsea looked a bit nervous.

“Hi Clarissa! Sorry we’re a bit late,” Corey said.

“More than a bit,” Clarissa said. “You’re 37 minutes late. Corey, work starts at 9. You are aware that these internships are paid, right?”

Chelsea stepped in now, touching Corey’s arm as she spoke, as if holding him back from responding. “Absolutely. It won’t happen again, Clarissa. We’re really sorry. We’re happy to stay a bit later to make up for it. Right, Corey?” Chelsea and Corey looked at each other.

“Um…,” was Corey’s reply. Clarissa could see his mind working, trying to come up with a reason why they couldn’t. But he only replied, “definitely,” and smiled again. And Chelsea smiled too.

Even though Corey was a theater kid, he had the face of a quarterback on a CW show: summer-blue eyes and artfully careless hair, jawline like a Berkshire ridge. When Clarissa had interviewed him for the job, she had immediately clocked that he was used to getting away with things. But his love for the theater was sincere; he had been coming to performances since he was a little kid. He had even performed here, though as Corey got older it became clear he was more suited to the work behind the stage than on it. And so he had gotten involved in tech crews, and had taken to it quickly. Corey’s father was a contractor in town and had taught him some basic construction techniques. He brought a lot to the local theater community and seemed serious, and so Clarissa had hired him for the internship. She hoped it would not prove to be a mistake.

“No, thanks Chelsea, let’s just get to work. I’d like to get the initial background painting done today, I want it to be finished and dry for Anton to draft the detailing on Thursday. And Chels, can you get started on inventory? Also, I need…” And so Clarissa laid out their day as they left the lobby and entered the theater proper. From here, they diverged, each moving to their respective tasks. Clarissa disappeared into the scene shop. By the time she looked up again, it was noon.

The redheaded theater director stretched, wiping her hands on her jeans. She had been mapping out the work that would be needed to get the sets built on time. Even though she was mostly on her laptop, she liked working here in the shop, surrounded by the physical reminders of her labor. She strolled out of the shop, intending to check on her tardy charges, when she spied someone slipping around the curtain onto the stage. Startled, she rushed after them. It was only a dozen steps to the heavy red curtain, and she pushed through and was blinded. The stage lights were all on full blast. Clarissa could feel the heat from them, a bright hose of warm yellow light. It took her a second to adjust her eyes, and by the time she did the theater was empty. But she hadn’t heard anyone leave. She stood blinking on the stage, confused, trying to figure out what had just happened. But then she noticed something else: the background that had been propped up on stage was still there. And it was bleeding.

Clarissa gasped. But then she frowned and stepped closer. It wasn’t bleeding: it was leaking red paint. And then Clarissa gasped again: Corey had done the requested painting, but somehow the background had been left under the lights, and all the paint had melted. Reds and blues ran into each other; much of what ought to have been a townscape was now a mottled, copperish brown. There was no way to paint over this: it was ruined. The whole slat would have to be recut and redone. Clarissa marched out of the theater. Corey, she thought, or whoever had left these lights on, had a lot of explaining to do.

It took fifteen minutes to find Corey. He wasn’t in the lobby, or the men’s room, or outside the front door. Clarissa was passing the coat check when she heard a noise. She moved quickly to the lobby window and peered in. At first it looked empty, nothing but a quiet thicket of empty hangers. But then she looked down. Corey and Chelsea were lying on an old coat together. They were making out passionately, Corey with one hand in Chelsea’s unbuttoned jeans. Chelsea had her hand under Corey’s shirt. They hadn’t noticed her.

“Excuse me.”

The couple jerked apart, and Chelsea let out a yelp as she rolled over on her stomach and fumbled with her jeans. Corey just looked up at her. Clarissa could swear the look on his face was vaguely smug.

“Um, hi Clarissa.”

“Hi Corey. I…I really don’t know what to say.”

Clarissa sighed. She had suspected it might come to this. But she didn’t expect anything this bad, and definitely not in the first week.

“I need both of you to meet me in my office in five minutes. Before that, you will both go onstage and look at the set piece that’s there.”

With that, Clarissa turned and walked away. Behind her, she heard Chelsea whimper.


The stern quartz visage of the grandfather clock was poor comfort to the fidgeting miscreants, as they stood before the theater director’s desk. Clarissa was writing, quietly and quickly. She filled one blank piece of paper, in a fluid but legible hand, and tearing it out of her notebook, began to copy the note again on a fresh sheet of paper. Corey and Chelsea, unsure what to do, merely stood in silence. Corey was mostly stoic, but Chelsea swayed gently, as though buffeted by a steady breeze.

At last, Clarissa completed her second note, and set her pen down. Then she set the two matching pages before her, and looked up at the two individuals.

“What I have here are two matching letters of termination. They explain everything you’ve both done today, including your tardiness, your decision to leave the stage lights on, and the blatant disrespect to me and this theater and yourselves by engaging in sexual activity while on the job.” At this last part, Chelsea cringed and turned scarlet.

“Before we proceed, Chelsea: did you turn on the overhead stage lights?”

Chelsea, miserable, only nodded.

“And were you so distracted that you forgot to turn them off?”

Another nod.

“And Corey, did you leave the painted background on stage, where you know things shouldn’t be left for this very reason, or did someone move it?”

“No ma’am.” Clarissa noticed that Corey’s demeanor was a bit different here than she had seen before.

“No ma’am what?”

“No ma’am, I left the set piece out.”

“And you were also too distracted to notice and fix your mistake?”

This time, Corey also nodded.

“I see. So I have the facts right. And I don’t need to spell out the impact your actions today will have on this theater’s schedule and its budget. You both know enough of what we do here to understand the level of damage you’ve caused.”

She placed a hand on one of the letters. “These summaries are not for you. Instead, I intend to send them both to your parents. As longtime patrons of this theater, and friends of mine, I want them to know exactly why I have to fire you both. Frankly, I don’t trust either of you enough right now to tell them the truth, and I can’t stand the idea of our friendships being something else you ruin by neglecting the truth.”

At this, Chelsea started crying. Corey silently took her hand, but he looked close to tears himself.

“Please, Clarissa, is there…like what can we do to, like, have you not send those letters.” Corey looked at her pleadingly.

“What you both did was so disrespectful. Not even just irresponsible, which I would understand at your age, but truly disrespectful, to my time, to what we do here, to me who is ultimately responsible for putting on shows here.”

Clarissa thought for a minute. “There may be one other way to handle this, one that I think would accurately reflect the maturity level you’ve both shown today.” She leaned back. “Chelsea, what would happen if I sent this letter home?”

Chelsea looked taken aback. “I…I mean, I’d get in trouble.”

“Yes I know that. I’m asking what happens when you get in trouble.”

Chelsea blushed. Her parents were both supporters of the Birchbright program, and they both knew Clarissa. She was pretty sure Clarissa knew the answer already.

“I’d just, I don’t know. Like, it depends on, um, like what I did, I guess.”

“Chelsea Brewer, if I gave this letter to your parents right now, tell me exactly what would happen to you.”

Chelsea considered running away, just fleeing this cramped office and out of the theater entirely. But then the older woman would just send the letter. And that would make everything worse. So, stammering, she muttered that she would be punished.

“Punished how?”

“You know.”

“Okay then.” Clarissa took out her phone and carefully framed the letter in her camera app. She took the picture and deliberately opened her texts and began scrolling for Mrs. Brewer’s name.

“Wait! Fine, I’d…get spanked.”

Clarissa paused. “Tell me more, or I’ll hit send right now.”

Meanwhile, standing uneasily next to her, Corey displayed a concerned expression. Chelsea, were she to look up from the carpet, might interpret this expression as shock at her admission. In fact, it was fear that he might be next.

“Chelsea, now.”

“What do you want me to say? I’d get spanked, probably by my mom.”

“With what? Where? Over your clothes?”

“With her hand, and I mean, a hairbrush usually. Or a belt. For this maybe a belt, I guess. Not…not over my clothes.”

Clarissa’s eyes narrowed, but she only said, “fine, that will do for now. And you, Corey? Your father was so excited about this opportunity for you. How do you think he’d react?”

“No…I mean, not good, ma’am.”

“And what would happen to you?”

“I’d…I’d get spanked too.”

“I’m sure you’re not expecting me to let you off the hook. Tell me more.”

Corey pouted. He gave Clarissa his best puppy look, looking out from under his hair, his riverine eyes glowing with the light of a thousand second chances. But Clarissa returned his gaze, unmoved. They stood like that for a moment, until Clarissa looked away, and began scrolling for a new name in her contacts.

“Okay, okay, I’d get the belt. From my dad. He…he makes me pull down my pants, and my underwear, in the garage. We have to go to the garage, I mean, and he spanks me with the belt there. I bend over a saw horse he has.”

“You bare your bottom after you bend over?”

“Yeah. I mean,” and here she could see his brain calculate the risks of a lie, “sometimes.”

“And what happens at other times, Corey?”

“I have to…ah man, do I have to?”

“You have two choices, young man. This is one. You know the other.”

“Yeah,” he sighed. “So like, I guess, like, I have to pull them down, my pants and stuff, in the kitchen, and walk out to the garage like that.”

Clarissa smiled reluctantly. “Your pants and stuff? You mean your underwear? So you walk to the garage with your bottom on display, and then you get a belt spanking when you’re there, bending over the saw horse?”

Corey was twisting his hands together as she said this, and looking down, and bouncing. He nodded without looking up.

“Corey, look at me. Chelsea, you too.”

After a moment, they both did so.

“I’m not asking you this to be cruel. I know you’re both still spanked at home. I didn’t know all the details, especially about yours, Corey, but I’ve had enough chats with your parents to know their expectations. I’m not being cruel, but I am trying to embarrass you a bit. Because frankly, you embarrassed me when you made me find you that way.”

Clarissa put down the phone she was still holding. She leaned back in her chair, studying the two interns before her. Then she reached into a drawer and pulled out a paddle and placed it on the desk. It was wooden, with a handle about a foot long and a thin oval head. It was made of a dark wood, and the seat of its blade was smooth.

“I am also reminding you that what I’m about to offer you is nothing new. You have both behaved like spoiled children, with absolutely no appreciation for the opportunity you’ve been given. Do you have any idea how rare a paid internship is at a regional theater? This is a rare privilege, and you’ve treated it like a middle school class you can’t wait to ditch. So I am offering you this choice: get a good, hard spanking from me, both of you, in front of each other. Or I send both your parents photos of these termination letters, and let them deal with you at home.”

As Clarissa finished speaking, a momentary silence settled on the room. Corey and Chelsea at first looked down, almost in unison. It was as if the weight of the choice was more than each could bear. But then it was Chelsea that spoke first. “I’ll do it…ma’am,” she said.

“You’ll take the spanking?”

“Yes.”

“It’s going to be a real spanking, you realize that, right? With my hand and this paddle, and I’m going to expose your bottom, and you’re probably going to cry?”

“Yes, yes, I…yes.”

Clarissa nodded. “And you, Corey?”

He was frowning. Again, Clarissa imagined options and escape routes populating in his mind, then rapidly being discarded, one by one. It was like watching a frog try to hop out of a bucket that was too high for it.

At last, he nodded. “Me too.”

“You too? You will also be receiving a bare bottom spanking from me?”

“Yeah.”

“Corey Bloom, try that again. Full sentences, please.”

“Yes…uh, yes ma’am, I will also be…um, I’ll also be receiving like a spanking on my bare bottom, from you.”

Clarissa stood up. “Right then. I think you’ve both chosen well. Now both of you please take off your shoes and your jeans. You can keep your socks and underwear on for now.”

They both looked at her, aghast. “You mean, um, like right now?” Chelsea asked.

“Yes, right now. I told you this was going to be embarrassing. That continues right now. Now get going.”

Another beat, and then they both began. Chelsea bent down and started unlacing the pair of faded doc martens she wore. When she slipped them off, Clarissa saw that she was wearing little white socks with bumblebees on them. The girl then unbuttoned and unzipped the snug acid-washed jeans she wore. They were artfully torn at each knee, revealing fishnets beneath. Chelsea stood and tried to tug them down. “They’re tight,” she said apologetically, as Clarissa waited.

“Not too tight for Corey’s hands to get inside though, right?”

Chelsea blushed and said nothing, wiggling the pale denim over her generous hips, and down, and off, the fishnets too. From habit she disentangled them and folded both neatly and set them on her boots. Her cheeky white panties matched her socks, right down to the bumblebees. Chelsea blushed deeply at this reveal, and Clarissa couldn’t help but smile.

“Take off the sweater too, please.” Chelsea had a long black sweater that hung halfway down her bottom, and Clarissa decided it would get in the way. Reluctantly, Chelsea unfolded herself from it, and stood there in just her tank top and underwear.

Meanwhile, Corey had exploded out of his pants. He wore dark jeans that fit him loosely, and a grey Red Sox hoodie. Without being told to, he pulled the hoodie off, tossing it in a pile near his jeans. His sneakers were likewise haphazardly shed, and they lay on the floor a few feet apart. Clarissa looked from Chelsea’s neat pile to Corey’s spread, and decided to choose her battles. She regarded them both standing there, shirt and socks and underwear.

“Now, you’re both going to turn around and face the wall, pull your underwear down, and show me your bottoms.”

Clarissa was surprised when they both obeyed immediately. Chelsea lowered her underwear to her knees, and Corey yanked his all the way to his ankles. Two white, well-formed bottoms appeared. She hadn’t expected cooperation this quickly. It reinforced her thought that discipline, being what both were used to, was the best way to reach them after all. And so she resolved to deepen that headspace for them as much as she could.

“Well, look at you two, bottoms bare and ready for a spanking. Not such cool adults now, are we?”

“No ma’am,” they replied quietly, in harmony.

“No indeed. Now, which one would you like to be the first to go over my knee?”

Corey turned slightly, and began to speak, but Chelsea stopped him, putting a hand on his shoulder the way she had done when they’d first arrived. “Please, Cor, can I? I’m…,” and her voice started to break. “I’m so scared and just, I’m so ashamed. I’m sorry ma’am. Can I, can I just get it over with?”

Corey just nodded, and Clarissa came forward and took the girl by the hand. She led her to a cramped but serviceable couch in the corner of the office. Instead of taking the girl right over her knee, though, Clarissa put her hands on her bare hips and pulled her in close, and looked up into the girl’s eyes.

“Chelsea, sweetie, when you’re getting a spanking from your mom, what does she make you ask?”

“Oh nooo, no, please ma’am. Please, I don’t want to.”

“Chelsea, now. Or we can wait.”

And they did, for just a moment. But then Chelsea did a little stomp, and said, “ma’am, will you please punish my bottom for my behavior, so I can be the best girl I can be?”

Clarissa gave Chelsea a warm smile, and took her hands.

“And how should I punish your bottom, sweetie?”

“With a good spanking, please.”

“Okay then, sweetie. I will.”

And with that, Clarissa pulled the girl over her lap. She ran a hand over the snow-white bottom and gave it a gentle squeeze. Chelsea whimpered. Then Clarissa raised her hand and began to spank her. And for the next four minutes, Clarissa reddened and warmed every inch of the girl’s full and dimpled bottom, while Chelsea whined and then sobbed and then begged. Periodically Clarissa would scold her gently as she spanked, reminding her of how special the theater program was, and how it needed to be respected, and how disrespectful and careless the girl had been. Until at last, her hand ceased its fiery work. Chelsea lay sobbing, trying to apologize through a flash flood of tears. Clarissa rubbed her back and whispered that she had done so well. And that it wasn’t quite over but she was being very brave. After a minute, Chelsea let herself be lifted up off the older woman’s lap. Clarissa gave her a kiss on the forehead, and told her to scoot into the far corner, opposite the clock. Chelsea tucked in, hands in front of her and red bottom on display. Clarissa had suspected she was no stranger to time-out time in the corner, and her familiarity with Clarissa’s expectations confirmed it. Now Clarissa turned to the other bottom in the middle of the room, and the tall boy it was attached to.

“Corey, turn around, and do not under any circumstances cover yourself.”

Corey had started to turn around, hands cupped in front of him, and he paused, hearing this. His hands moved apart, then back, then, with visible effort, back again to his sides. Slowly he turned, shamefaced, and walked over to stand by Clarissa’s knee without being told. Clarissa put her hands on his hips and positioned Corey right in front of her.

“Now, do you remember what Chelsea asked me?”

“I, uh, it was kinda complicated.”

“Well sweetie, why don’t you give it a try, and we can run through it as many times as you need until you get it exactly right.”

Corey sighed, looked up at the ceiling once, and finding no help there, looked into Clarissa’s eyes and repeated Chelsea’s statement word for word: “ma’am, will you please punish my bottom for my behavior, so that I can be the best boy I can be?”

Clarissa chuckled. “Well, look at you, remembering such a complicated question. Yes, young man, I would be happy to punish your bottom for you. What do you think is the best punishment for it?”

“A spanking, ma’am.”

“Yes, Corey, I agree. Now let’s get you over.” And the woman pulled the young man forward over her lap. She lifted the tee shirt and ran her hand over his bottom. It was round and firm, and she gave it a gentle squeeze. “You have a very handsome bottom, young man,” she said.

“Thank you, ma’am.”

With that, she began to spank him. The spanking proceeded quite similarly to the first. Clarissa could tell Corey was trying to be brave, but from the first swats he was squirming and grunting, and very soon he was crying openly. The theater director noted with amusement that he had started crying much sooner than Chelsea had. After another four or so minutes, Corey was a thoroughly spanked young man, and Clarissa brought the session to an end. She rubbed Corey’s back as he realized the spanking was over, and tried to compose himself.

After a minute, Corey was instructed to stand up. He did so reluctantly, embarrassed at the show he had made. But Chelsea had been dutifully facing the corner the whole time, the bright streaks across her bottom already starting to fade. Corey was led to a different corner, and installed with his hands in front of him. Clarissa deduced that this was not part of his normal punishment, and she reminded him not to speak or turn around until told to. Then she sat down at her desk and returned to her laptop. Occasionally she glanced up to admire the two bare behinds decorating her office. But mostly, she worked quietly. Aside from a couple sniffles, the interns were quiet.

After 15 minutes, Clarissa stood up. “Okay you two, you’re almost done, but I promised you the paddle. I think a good, hard paddling will make this lesson stick. Corey, I want you bent over my desk, here. Chelsea, other side, so that you’re facing each other.” The interns obeyed, leaning over opposite sides of the dark wooden desk, bottoms in the air and eyes on one another. Clarissa lifted the paddle off the desk. The sound of wood scraping on wood sounded for a moment in the tensely quiet room. The woman visibly deliberated, then decided to step behind Chelsea, thinking that to watch his paramour be disciplined would be a more painful beginning for Corey than feeling the paddle himself. Clarissa lined up the round wooden head, and gave Chelsea six hard swats, barely pausing in between. Chelsea yelped, and at the sixth swat her knees buckled. Clarissa guided her back into position with hands on her hips, gently, and then with one hand she pushed down on the small of her back. The other hand she placed on Chelsea’s bottom, just resting it there for a moment. They stayed like that until Clarissa felt Chelsea’s breathing return to normal. “Keep your bottom still, sweetie. Understand?” Chelsea replied that she did, and Clarissa moved to the other side of the desk.

“How does it feel, watching Chelsea get her bottom paddled?” she asked, resting the paddle on Corey’s backside now.

“I feel really bad,” Corey said, and there was a deep shame in his voice. “It’s my fault, all of it, I distracted her.”

“I imagine that is so, young man. But you are both responsible for your own actions. Still, I appreciate this confession. Would you like to take Chelsea’s last set for her? That means you’ll get 18 instead of 12.”

Corey swallowed. “Um, can I just get…no, I mean yes, I…I’ll take them. The 18. Ma’am.”

“Good boy,” Clarissa said, and meant it. And with that, she proceeded to paddle Corey. The first six were delivered hard and fast, like Chelsea’s. But after that she took her time, swatting one side of his bottom, then the other. Occasionally she would pause to rub his behind gently, and whisper encouragement. Corey was soon once again sobbing openly, and Chelsea, afraid to look away, watched him the whole time.

At last the paddling was over. Stroke 18 came hard across the boy’s sit spots, leaving a fiery brand behind. Clarissa let him lie over the desk for a full minute before ordering both of them up. She had them stand in front of her side by side, and then turn. “Show me your spanked bottoms, you two. Good.” She admired her work on them, Chelsea’s blushing backside and Corey’s tomato-toned butt. She told them to turn around again, and enfolded them in a big hug. They both hugged back. Clarissa told them both to get dressed. “And that will be the end of that. But listen, I am claiming full spanking privileges over both of you, and I will be sharing this fact with your parents. I’m confident they’ll agree. But I won’t mention this particular incident. I expect stellar behavior from now on, or you’ll be right back over my knee.” The two young people blushed, but they nodded.

After that, Clarissa told them they could have the rest of the day off, but that they were expected to come 40 minutes early the next day to make up for their tardiness the day before. If it was 8:21, they might as well come straight to her and ask for a spanking, because they were getting one. Corey assured her they would be on time. “We’ll see, young man,” Clarissa said, as he and Chelsea put on their coats and went out into the rain. “We will see.”

More by Conor Grayson

Kindle Unlimited Also available to read free with Kindle Unlimited:

See all stories by Conor Grayson →